Home » asbestos shingles » Cost Analysis: Installing Vinyl Siding Over Asbestos Shingles – A Comprehensive Guide

Cost Analysis: Installing Vinyl Siding Over Asbestos Shingles – A Comprehensive Guide

Vinyl siding is a popular choice for home exteriors, offering a durable and cost-effective solution. When it comes to homes with asbestos shingles, the decision to install vinyl siding can be complicated by health concerns, additional preparation requirements, and overall cost.

This article aims to unravel the complexities of installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles, providing a detailed look at the factors that influence cost, the installation process, and maintenance considerations.

Before making a decision, it is essential to understand the potential hazards of asbestos shingles as well as the steps required to prepare the surface, install the siding, and maintain the finished product. By exploring each of these aspects in detail, homeowners can make informed decisions and plan effectively for their vinyl siding installation project.

Asbestos Shingles

Asbestos shingles, widely used in the past due to their fire-resistant and insulating properties, are now considered hazardous. They pose serious health risks, such as lung cancer, asbestosis, and mesothelioma, if inhaled or disturbed during renovation activities. It's important to exercise extreme caution while handling asbestos shingles, as their fibers can become airborne and cause severe respiratory issues.

Discuss the dangers of asbestos shingles

Asbestos shingles pose significant health risks due to the release of tiny fibers when damaged or disturbed. These fibers can be inhaled and become trapped in the lungs, resulting in several diseases:

Asbestosis, a chronic lung ailment that causes scarring in the lungs, resulting in difficulty breathing;
Lung cancer, caused by long-term exposure to asbestos; and
Mesothelioma, a rare form of cancer that affects the lining of the lungs, heart, or abdomen.

Elaborate on the process of identifying asbestos shingles

Identifying asbestos shingles is a crucial initial step:

Check the age of the home, as most homes constructed before the 1980s are likely to have asbestos shingles;
Observe the shingles' appearance: rough, brittle, or easily crumbled asbestos shingles are more likely to release fibers;
Inspect the underside of the shingles, if possible, for a woven or paper-like texture;
Consult a professional asbestos inspector or abatement contractor for a comprehensive and definitive assessment.

Share safety measures to take when handling asbestos shingles

When handling asbestos shingles, follow strict safety protocols:

Keep the shingles wet to reduce the probability of airborne fibers;
Use personal protective equipment (PPE), such as respirators, disposable coveralls, gloves, and eye protection;
Minimize the creation of dust or debris;
Avoid sanding, scraping, breaking, or sawing asbestos materials;
Never use power tools or high-pressure water;
Dispose of asbestos materials according to local regulations, typically in double-wrapped, labeled bags.

Preparing the Surface

Installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles involves a critical step: preparing the surface. Proper surface preparation ensures a secure and long-lasting installation. We've broken down the process into three s: cleaning and drying, repairing damaged shingles, and removing protrusions.

Cleaning and Drying

Before installing vinyl siding, clean the asbestos shingles thoroughly to remove dirt, mildew, and other contaminants. Use a mild detergent, a long-handled brush, and a garden hose. Avoid power washers, which can damage the shingles. Rinse from top to bottom to prevent water from seeping under the shingles.After cleaning, allow the shingles to dry completely.

Drying usually takes 24 to 48 hours, depending on the weather conditions. Ensure the shingles are dry to prevent mold growth and to ensure proper adhesion of the vinyl siding.

"Prompt and thorough drying is crucial to prevent water damage and mold growth."

Repairing Damaged Shingles

Inspect the asbestos shingles for damage, such as cracks, breaks, or loose shingles. Repair these issues before installing the vinyl siding to ensure a smooth and secure installation. Use a specialized asbestos-safe adhesive or epoxy to repair cracks and breaks.

For loose or damaged shingles, replace them with new ones, following local regulations for asbestos disposal.

"Skipping the repair step may lead to water damage, mold, and potential asbestos exposure."

Removing Protrusions

Remove any protrusions, such as pipes, vents, or antennas, from the asbestos shingles. These protrusions can interfere with the vinyl siding installation and may cause damage over time. Use a sealant or flashing to cover the holes left by the protrusions.

This will prevent water damage and ensure the vinyl siding lies flat against the surface.

"Leaving protrusions in place may result in vinyl siding damage and reduced energy efficiency."

Installing Vinyl Siding

Installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles is a great way to modernize the appearance of a home while also providing added protection from the elements. With a few extra steps and considerations, the installation process is similar to that of installing vinyl siding over other materials like wood or aluminum siding.

Preparing the Asbestos Shingles

Before installing the vinyl siding, the asbestos shingles must be properly prepared. This involves:

Inspecting the shingles for signs of damage or wear
Repairing any damaged areas
Cleaning the shingles with a detergent solution and rinsing thoroughly
Applying a polyurethane foam insulation over the shingles for added insulation and to create a smoother surface for the vinyl siding to adhere to
Allowing the insulation to dry completely

Installing the Vinyl Siding

The installation of the vinyl siding involves the following steps:

Install a starter strip along the bottom edge of the wall, nailing it into the studs or sheathing. The starter strip should be level and should extend past the ends of the wall.
Cut the first piece of siding to the appropriate length, adding an extra 1/4 inch for expansion.
Slide the bottom edge of the siding under the starter strip, allowing the top edge to overlap the starter strip by 1/2 inch.
Nail the siding into place using vinyl-coated nails, spacing them 16 inches apart. The nails should be long enough to penetrate the sheathing but not so long that they protrude through the other side.
Install the remaining pieces of siding, overlapping each piece by 1 inch.
At the corners, cut the siding to fit and install corner posts.
Install J-channels around windows and doors.
Install soffit and fascia pieces to complete the installation.

Comparison with Other Materials

Compared to installing vinyl siding over other materials like wood or aluminum, the process of installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles is relatively similar. However, the added step of applying a polyurethane foam insulation over the shingles may add some additional time and cost.

It's important to take the necessary precautions when working with asbestos, and to properly dispose of any asbestos-containing materials.Vinyl siding offers several advantages over other materials, including its low maintenance and durability. It is also more energy efficient than other materials, due to its insulating properties.

Cost Analysis

Installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles involves costs related to labor, materials, and other factors that can affect the overall price. In this section, we will discuss the factors affecting the cost, breakdown of the costs, and compare it with other siding options

Factors Affecting Cost

The cost of installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles is influenced by several factors:

Size of the house

Larger houses will require more siding and labor, increasing the overall cost.

Complexity of the job

Homes with unusual shapes, multiple stories, or intricate designs will take longer to side, driving up labor costs.

Removal of asbestos

If the asbestos shingles are not in good condition or if local regulations require their removal, additional costs will be incurred.

Insulation

Adding insulation during the installation can increase the cost but improve energy efficiency.

Location

Prices for labor and materials vary by region, with more expensive areas having higher installation costs.

Breakdown of Costs

Below is a breakdown of the costs involved, based on a national average for a single-story, 1,500-square-foot home:

Materials

$7,500

$10,000

Includes siding, insulation, and underlayment.

Asbestos Removal (if needed)

$1,500

$3,000

Cost depends on the size of the house and the condition of the asbestos shingles.

Labor

$3,500

$5,000

Includes removal of existing shingles, installation of new materials, and cleanup.

Disposal

$200

$500

Covers costs of transporting and disposing of old materials.

Permits

$200

$500

fees for obtaining building permits.

Comparison with Other Siding Options

Compared to other siding options, vinyl over asbestos shingles can be a cost-effective choice:

Wood siding

More expensive than vinyl, with higher maintenance costs.

Fiber cement siding

Similar cost to vinyl, but requires professional installation and maintenance.

Brick or stone

Much more expensive and requires specialized labor.

Aluminum siding

Similar cost to vinyl, but less durable and less visually appealing.

Vinyl siding over asbestos shingles often offers the best balance of cost, durability, and ease of installation.

Maintenance and Longevity

When it comes to maintaining vinyl siding installed over asbestos shingles, the good news is that vinyl siding requires minimal upkeep compared to other types of siding. The main advantage of vinyl siding is that it does not require painting or scraping – a significant time and cost-saver.One of the only maintenance requirements for vinyl siding is cleaning it when needed.

You can clean your vinyl siding with a simple solution of water and a mild detergent using a long-handled, soft-bristle brush. Avoid using abrasive cleaners or tools that may damage or discolor the siding. Regularly inspect your vinyl siding for any possible damage, and fix any issues as they arise.

Longevity compared to other siding materials

While vinyl siding has a relatively long lifespan, other siding materials have different life expectancy ranges:

Wood siding

Typically lasts between 20-40 years, depending on the quality of the materials and the level of maintenance provided

Fiber cement siding

Lasts between 25-50 years or more, requiring occasional painting and maintenance

Aluminum siding

Lasts around 25-40 years but is more susceptible to damage from hail or impactVinyl siding, on the other hand, tends to last around 25-40 years or even longer, depending on local weather conditions and installation quality.

Tips for increasing the longevity of vinyl siding

To ensure the vinyl siding lasts as long as possible, follow these maintenance tips:

Clean the siding annually

A simple cleaning will remove dirt, mildew, and mold that could damage the vinyl over time

Schedule regular inspections

Annually inspect the siding for cracks, warping, or other signs of damage, and fix any issues promptly

Repair any damage

Prompt repairs will help prevent further deterioration caused by moisture or other environmental factors

Install quality products

Choosing a reputable manufacturer and high-quality products will increase the likelihood of a long-lasting vinyl siding installation

Professional installation

Ensure your vinyl siding is installed by experienced professionals who understand proper installation techniques and consider local climate conditions

Outcome Summary

Installing vinyl siding over asbestos shingles involves a considerable investment of time, effort, and money. Considering various factors, including health risks, surface preparation, installation techniques, and maintenance, can result in a successful project that enhances the appearance and value of the home.

By understanding the process, homeowners can mitigate potential hazards, optimize their investment, and enjoy the many benefits of vinyl siding.